Free consultation by phone or Zoom · Serving Harris, Galveston and Brazoria CountiesQuestions about your case? Call (817) 800-8333
Smith Law Firm, Attorney at Law

Home  /  Practice Areas  /  Complex Business Litigation

Complex Business Litigation

Complex business litigation

When a business dispute threatens your company or your investment, you need someone who understands both the courtroom and the numbers. Jeffrey J. Smith holds an M.B.A. and a finance degree.

Disputes where the details decide the outcome

When a business dispute threatens your company, your investment or your property, it can consume your time, your cash and your attention. These cases are often won or lost on contracts, financial records and careful preparation. You need an attorney who understands both the courtroom and the numbers.

Jeffrey J. Smith is a Texas trial attorney who has been licensed since 1996. Before law school he earned a Bachelor of Science in Finance, cum laude, and an M.B.A. with Distinction from Cal Poly San Luis Obispo. Over his career he has handled both litigation and transactional work, including reviewing and drafting real estate purchase and sale contracts, business documents and other agreements. He understands how deals are put together and where they can fall apart.

Matters Jeffrey handles

  • Breach of contract and disputes over business agreements
  • Real estate litigation, including purchase and sale disputes and commercial property disputes
  • Oil and gas disputes, including lease and royalty issues
  • Bad faith insurance claims, when an insurer wrongfully delays or denies a claim
  • Fraud and misrepresentation in business dealings
  • Interference with contracts and business relationships

Breach of contract

Contract disputes are at the heart of most business litigation. In Texas, a breach of contract claim generally requires showing that there was a valid contract, that you performed or were excused from performing your part, that the other side failed to perform its part, and that the breach caused you damages.

Those damages can include the benefit of the bargain you lost, lost profits that can be proven with reasonable certainty, and out-of-pocket costs. In many cases, Texas law also allows a party who wins a breach of contract claim and recovers damages to recover reasonable attorney's fees. Contract claims generally must be filed within four years, although the contract itself may contain notice requirements or other terms that affect timing.

Terms that often decide the case

Many disputes turn on a few clauses that were easy to skim when the deal was signed. These include:

  • Arbitration clauses, which may require the dispute to be decided outside of court
  • Forum selection and choice of law clauses, which set where and under which state's law a case is heard
  • Notice and cure provisions, which may require written notice and a chance to fix the problem
  • Limitation of liability and damages waivers
  • Attorney's fees provisions
  • Termination rights and renewal terms

Real estate litigation

Real estate disputes can involve large sums and property that is hard to replace. Jeffrey has reviewed and drafted real estate purchase and sale contracts and related documents, and he has handled real estate litigation. Common disputes include a buyer or seller backing out of a deal, fights over earnest money, failures to disclose known problems, title and boundary issues, easements and access, and disputes under commercial leases.

Oil and gas disputes

Oil and gas remains central to the Texas economy, and so do the disputes that come with it. Jeffrey has handled oil and gas litigation. These cases can involve the terms of a lease, whether royalties have been calculated and paid correctly, disagreements between working interest owners, surface use and damage to land, and the contracts between operators, contractors and service companies. They often require a close reading of documents and a clear explanation of the numbers.

Bad faith insurance claims

Businesses and individuals pay premiums so that coverage is there when they need it. When an insurer unreasonably denies or delays a valid claim, Texas law may provide a remedy. The Texas Insurance Code prohibits unfair settlement practices and sets deadlines for insurers to acknowledge, investigate and pay claims. Texas law also recognizes a duty of good faith and fair dealing in many insurance relationships. Depending on the facts, an insured may be able to recover the policy benefits plus additional damages, interest and attorney's fees. Many of these claims require written notice to the insurer, often 60 days, before a lawsuit is filed.

Fraud and interference with business relationships

Some disputes are not only about a broken promise but about being misled. Fraud claims can arise when someone makes a false statement of fact, knowing it is false or recklessly, intending for you to rely on it, and you do rely on it and are harmed. Fraud claims in Texas generally must be filed within four years. Claims for wrongful interference with a contract or business relationship involve a third party who knowingly disrupts your agreements or dealings, and they generally must be filed within two years. These claims can carry the possibility of exemplary damages in serious cases.

Commercial lease disputes

Commercial leases are long documents that can carry large obligations for years. Disputes can arise over unpaid rent, repairs and maintenance, common area charges, assignment and subletting, renewal options and early termination. In Texas, a landlord generally has a duty to make reasonable efforts to reduce its damages when a tenant leaves early, which can affect how much the tenant owes. Whether you are a landlord or a tenant, the lease language and the way each side acted are central to the case.

Damages and other remedies

In a business case, the goal is usually to put you in the position you would have been in if the other side had kept its word. Depending on the claim, that can include direct damages, consequential damages, lost profits that can be shown with reasonable certainty, and interest. In some cases, money is not enough, and a court may be asked to order a party to do something or stop doing something, for example through an injunction, or to complete a real estate sale through specific performance. Understanding which remedies are realistic helps shape strategy from the start.

Arbitration or court?

Many business contracts include an arbitration clause. Arbitration can be faster and more private than a lawsuit, but it also has trade-offs: the right to appeal is very limited, the parties often pay the arbitrator's fees, and discovery may be narrower. Both the Texas Arbitration Act and the Federal Arbitration Act can apply. Whether a dispute must go to arbitration, and whether that helps or hurts your position, is one of the first questions to answer.

If your business has been sued

Being served with a lawsuit is stressful, but a calm, prompt response protects your options. Note the date you were served and calendar the answer deadline. Check your insurance, since a commercial general liability policy or another policy may provide a defense, and most policies require prompt notice of a claim. Preserve your records, and avoid contacting the other side about the dispute without advice. Your response may include defenses, and in some cases, claims of your own against the party that sued you.

How a business lawsuit unfolds

Business litigation can feel unpredictable. Knowing the general stages can help you plan and make decisions:

  1. Early review and demand. Your attorney reviews the agreements and records and may send a demand letter or a required pre-suit notice. Many disputes resolve at this stage.
  2. Filing and response. A lawsuit begins with a petition. A defendant in a Texas state court lawsuit generally must file an answer by 10:00 a.m. on the Monday after 20 days have passed since being served. Missing that deadline can lead to a default judgment.
  3. Discovery. The parties exchange documents, answer written questions and take depositions. In business cases, this often includes financial records, emails and expert analysis.
  4. Motions. Either side may ask the court to decide some or all of the case before trial, for example through summary judgment.
  5. Mediation. Texas courts commonly require mediation, and many business disputes settle there.
  6. Trial. If the case does not resolve, it is decided by a judge or jury.
  7. Appeal. After trial, either side may have the right to ask a higher court to review the result.

Texas has an expedited process for many lawsuits seeking $250,000 or less, designed to limit cost and time. Texas also now has a statewide Business Court for certain large commercial disputes. Where a case belongs can affect strategy, timing and cost.

Resolving a dispute without a trial

Most business disputes end without a trial. A well-prepared demand letter, a direct conversation between decision-makers, or a structured negotiation can resolve a matter early and save significant time and expense. Mediation, where a neutral mediator helps the parties work toward an agreement, resolves many cases that are already in litigation. A settlement can also offer options a court cannot, such as a payment plan, a revised contract or an ongoing business relationship. Even so, strong settlements tend to come from a position of strength, which is why Jeffrey prepares a case with trial in mind. When the other side knows you are ready to go to court, it has a reason to negotiate seriously.

Before you file or respond

Whether you are thinking about suing or have just been sued, a few steps early on can protect your position:

  • Gather the documents. Collect the contract, amendments, invoices, payment records, emails and text messages.
  • Preserve everything. Do not delete emails, files or messages related to the dispute. Destroying evidence can hurt your case.
  • Read the notice provisions. Your contract may require written notice by a certain method before you can bring a claim.
  • Watch the deadlines. Limitations periods, notice periods and the deadline to answer a lawsuit can all affect your rights.
  • Be careful what you put in writing. Emails and messages sent during a dispute can become evidence.
  • Talk to an attorney early. An early review can help you understand your options and avoid mistakes that are hard to undo.

Why a business background matters

Business cases are not only about legal rules. They are about how a company makes money, what a contract was meant to accomplish, and what the financial records actually show. Jeffrey's degrees in finance and business administration help him read those records, work with accountants and experts, and explain the numbers clearly to a judge or jury. His years of transactional work help him see a dispute the way the deal was meant to work, and where it went wrong.

He has also practiced civil and criminal law side by side throughout his career. That breadth helps him anticipate how the other side may approach a case and find creative solutions.

How Jeffrey can help

  • Review your agreements, records and communications and explain where you stand
  • Identify the claims and defenses that may apply, and the deadlines that matter
  • Send demand letters and required notices
  • Negotiate with the other side and represent you in mediation
  • Prepare the case for trial and present it in court if it comes to that

Jeffrey enjoys taking on large firms and well-funded opponents, and he works directly with his clients as a solo practitioner. He represents businesses and individuals across Harris, Galveston and Brazoria Counties and throughout Texas, with consultations by phone or Zoom. If an insurance dispute arose from a crash, see his car accidents and truck accidents pages.

Common questions

What makes a business dispute "complex"?

Complex cases often involve large amounts of money, several parties, detailed financial records or specialized industries such as oil and gas or real estate.

Do all business disputes go to court?

No. Many are resolved through negotiation or mediation. Jeffrey can help you weigh the options and prepare for trial if it comes to that.

How long do I have to bring a breach of contract claim in Texas?

Contract claims generally must be filed within four years, but your contract may contain notice requirements or other terms that affect timing.

Can I recover attorney's fees?

In many cases, a party who wins a breach of contract claim and recovers damages can also recover reasonable attorney's fees under Texas law. Some contracts also include their own fee provisions.

I have just been sued. What should I do?

Do not ignore it. In a Texas state court case, an answer is generally due by 10:00 a.m. on the Monday after 20 days have passed since you were served. Talk to an attorney right away.

Is the consultation free?

Yes. Your first consultation is free, by phone or Zoom.

This page is general information, not legal advice. Every case is different.

Next step

Your case deserves a trial lawyer.

Tell Jeffrey what happened and learn what your options may be. The first consultation is free.

Call nowFree consultation